top of page
  • Writer's pictureSean

Can You Just Buy Compost?

Embarking on a green journey with dreams of lush gardens and vibrant plants? Let's dig into the concept of store-bought compost and discover if it's the golden ticket to your gardening success.

Yes, But...

Now, to answer the burning question: "Can you buy compost rather than make it yourself?" Absolutely! You can procure compost off-the-shelf, but being an informed consumer is key to ensuring you provide your plants with the best nourishment. Let's unravel the intricacies of store-bought compost together.

Benefits of Buying Compost:

Convenience and Time-saving: The immediate lure of store-bought compost lies in its convenience. For those with busy schedules or limited space, picking up a bag of compost from the store saves time and effort. With commercial compost, there's no need to wait months for decomposition; it's ready to use right off the shelf.

Consistency in Product Quality: Purchasing compost, especially from reputed brands, often ensures a consistent product quality. They're usually free from unwanted materials, and the nutrient content is predictable. This consistency ensures that your plants receive balanced nourishment every time.

Wide Range of Choices Tailored to Specific Needs: Store shelves offer a plethora of compost types, from vermicompost to mushroom compost. Each variety caters to specific plant needs, allowing gardeners to tailor their soil enrichment strategies.

When to Opt for DIY Composting

The Joy and Benefits of Making Your Own Compost: There's a certain satisfaction in witnessing organic waste transform into black gold for your garden. DIY composting is not just about waste reduction; it's a practice that cultivates patience, observation, and a deeper connection to the earth.

Environmental Advantages: DIY composting is a direct action against the escalating global waste problem. By composting at home, you’re reducing methane emissions from landfills – a significant step towards combatting climate change.

Tailoring Compost to Specific Garden Needs: The advantage of home composting is the control it offers. You can customize your compost's ingredients, ensuring your garden gets precisely what it needs. Plus, there's zero risk of unknown additives or contaminants.

Where to Buy Quality Compost

Local Nurseries and Garden Centers: Your local nurseries are not just places to buy plants. They often stock quality compost tailored to the needs of the local soil and climate. The expertise of the staff can guide you to the best product for your garden's specific requirements. Plus, it's always good to shop locally.

Big-Box Stores: Stores like Home Depot or Lowe's usually have a gardening section where you can find a range of compost products. While they offer convenience and often competitive prices, it's essential to check product reviews and ingredients to ensure you're getting a quality product.

Online Platforms: From Amazon to specialized gardening websites, the digital realm provides an array of compost options. However, always do your due diligence by reading reviews, checking return policies, and understanding the compost's origin.

Organic Farms: Some organic farms sell compost as a by-product of their farming practices. This compost is often rich and free from harmful chemicals. Plus, supporting local farms is a sustainable choice that reduces carbon footprints.

Interested in the journey from waste to compost? Dive into our article about the composting process here.

Reading Compost Labels: Decoding the Details

Ingredients and Components: Just as you'd scrutinize a food label, inspecting compost ingredients is paramount. Look for indicators of organic matter, like decomposed leaves, food waste, and manure. Avoid products with vague descriptions or unknown additives.

Organic vs. Non-organic Compost: While organic compost is derived from natural plant and animal waste, non-organic versions might contain synthetic fertilizers or sewage sludge. Always opt for certified organic products to ensure your garden remains chemical-free.

Nutrient Content and pH Levels: A good compost will list its nutrient content, including nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. Depending on your garden's needs, you can choose a product that offers the best nutrient balance. Also, check the pH level, especially if you're catering to plants that have specific soil pH requirements.

Common Types of Store-Bought Compost

Mushroom Compost: Derived from the agricultural residue of mushroom crops, this type of compost is renowned for its rich nutrient content. It’s a versatile medium, suitable for most plants. However, its alkaline nature means it might not be ideal for acid-loving plants like rhododendrons.

Vermicompost: Worms play a starring role in this composting process. As they consume organic waste, they excrete nutrient-rich castings. Vermicompost is an excellent soil conditioner, enhancing aeration and moisture retention.

Manure-based Composts (chicken, cow, horse): Animal manure, when properly composted, is a nutrient dynamo. Depending on the source (chicken, cow, horse), nutrient profiles can differ. It's a must to ensure that any manure-based product has been thoroughly composted to eliminate potential pathogens.

Green Waste Compost: Crafted from garden and kitchen waste, green waste compost is organic and sustainable. While its nutrient levels might be lower than other types, its capability to improve soil structure is commendable.

Potential Pitfalls & How to Avoid Them

Incomplete Decomposition: Signs and Why It Matters: Fresh or semi-decomposed materials in your compost can rob your soil of essential nitrogen as they continue to break down. The presence of recognizable plant materials or a sour smell are telltale signs. It's wise to let such compost mature before use or mix it with mature compost.

Contaminants or Unwanted Residues: The last thing you want is to introduce heavy metals or harmful residues into your garden. Ensure your compost source is trustworthy, and when in doubt, consider getting it tested. Most state agricultural extensions offer soil and compost testing services.

Overpriced Compost: Getting Value for Money: The price range for store-bought compost can be broad. Research, compare, and ensure you're not paying a premium for subpar quality. Sometimes, local compost might be both superior and more affordable than imported brands.

Mixing Store-Bought Compost with Existing Soil

Ratios and Guidelines: A general guideline is to mix one part compost with two parts native soil. However, for plants that love rich soils (like tomatoes), a 1:1 ratio works wonders. Always consult plant-specific needs.

Tips for Blending for Optimal Results: Ensure the compost and soil are well-integrated. This uniformity helps roots easily access the nutrients they need. A garden fork or rototiller can assist in achieving a well-blended mixture.

Adjusting for Plant-Specific Needs: While a general-purpose compost suits most plants, some plants have unique nutrient demands. For instance, roses love extra potassium. Thus, tailor your compost-soil mix to match plant preferences.

FAQ Corner: Quick Answers to Common Queries

How do I store leftover purchased compost?

Storage Environment: Compost retains its nutrients best when stored in a cool, dry place. If you’ve bought compost in a bag, ensure it's sealed tight to keep out excess moisture and unwanted pests.

Duration: While compost doesn’t exactly expire, it can lose some of its efficacy over extended periods. If stored properly, purchased compost can last for 2-3 years without significant nutrient loss.

Rejuvenation: If you’re using old compost, consider rejuvenating it by mixing it with fresh organic matter or a bit of worm castings. Is bagged compost as effective as homemade compost?

Nutrient Profile: The efficacy of bagged compost can be comparable to homemade variants, but it often depends on the brand and its quality. Some premium brands offer nutrient-rich compost that can rival the best homemade batches.

Additives: Unlike DIY compost, with store-bought options, there's a risk of undisclosed additives or fillers. This is where trusted brands and reading labels become crucial.

Environmental Impact: From an environmental perspective, making compost at home is a zero-waste option, whereas bagged compost comes with packaging and a carbon footprint from transportation.

Can I use compost alone or mix it with soil?

Pure Compost Usage: While using pure compost isn’t harmful, it may not always be optimal. Pure compost can be too rich for some plants and might retain too much moisture.

Optimal Mixing: Blending compost with garden soil offers the best of both worlds. It enriches the soil while ensuring adequate drainage and aeration, essential for root health.

Special Cases: For container gardening or raised beds, using a higher percentage of compost could be beneficial. Again, it boils down to the specific requirements of the plants in question.

Making an Informed Choice

While the convenience of buying compost cannot be overstated, there's an undeniable charm and satisfaction in creating your own. More than the nutrient-rich end product, the journey of composting can be a deeply educational and environmentally responsible endeavor. Whether you choose to buy or DIY, being informed ensures that your garden receives the best.

The Environmental Perspective: Beyond just gardening, our choices impact the world at large. Reducing waste, lowering carbon footprints, and supporting sustainable practices are as integral to the composting narrative as the blooming flowers in our gardens.


bottom of page