top of page
  • Writer's pictureSean

How Long Can You Leave Compost in a Compost Bin?

ready compost vs not ready compost

Think of compost like baking a cake: too long in the 'oven' and you might not get the results you want. So, how long is just right?

Crafting nutrient-rich soil through organic decomposition in a compost bin is an art and science combined. Each heap of compost goes through an intricate dance of microbial activity, temperature fluctuations, and elemental balance. But as with many natural processes, timing is crucial.

To the budding composter's question, "How long should compost remain in the bin?", the answer typically ranges from several months to a year. However, this isn't a one-size-fits-all answer. Leaving it in the bin for extended periods can impede the composting process, and by contrast, hurried removal might result in under-decomposed waste. Dive in with us as we unpack the secrets behind the composting timeline, leveraging compost science. Rest assured, you'll soon be well-equipped to optimize your composting endeavors.

Understanding the Composting Timeline:

1. Starting Fresh:

  • The first step to creating effective compost is understanding what happens in the initial stages. At this juncture, you've likely introduced a mix of greens (nitrogen-rich material) and browns (carbon-rich material) into the bin. This balance instigates the biological decomposition.

  • In the initial days, microbial activity takes the lead. Microorganisms begin breaking down the organic matter, predominantly feeding on the green materials. This activity causes the compost's temperature to rise, an indicator that decomposition has commenced.

  • However, this early phase doesn't last long. Within a week or two, as the easily decomposable materials are consumed, the compost's temperature begins to decline. This transition is the cue for the second phase: the active composting phase.

2. Middle of the Journey:

  • This phase is characterized by heat and active composting. As the microbial activity intensifies, thermophilic microbes (heat-loving) take over the scene. They thrive in the rising temperatures, which can reach up to 160°F (70°C). According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), this elevated temperature not only speeds up the decomposition but also kills off weed seeds and pathogens.

  • For the pile to maintain this active composting phase, it requires a balance. The carbon-to-nitrogen ratio is crucial here, with an ideal ratio hovering around 25-30:1. A deviation from this balance, either too much green or too much brown, can disrupt the microbial activity.

  • Around 1 to 2 months into this phase, you'd notice the pile shrinking in size. This reduction is a good sign, indicating that decomposition is in full swing. It's essential to ensure regular turning and maintain proper moisture levels to sustain this momentum.

3. The Finish Line:

  • As the composting process approaches the end, the temperature in the pile starts to drop, signaling the decline of thermophilic activity. At this point, the pile transitions back to mesophilic microbes which operate at moderate temperatures.

  • The compost should now exhibit a dark, crumbly, and soil-like texture. The distinct smell of earthiness, a far cry from the initial putrid odors, would be evident. This is the phase where the compost reaches its maturity, rich in nutrients, and is almost ready for use.

  • However, before you decide to use this compost, it's essential to let it cure for a few more weeks. Curing allows beneficial microbes to further break down any remaining materials, making it more stable and beneficial for plants. It also helps in fine-tuning the compost's moisture and ensuring a balanced pH, creating the perfect soil amendment.

Factors Affecting Composting Speed:

1. Materials Added:

  • Different materials decay at various rates. Green materials, which are rich in nitrogen like vegetable scraps, coffee grounds, and fresh grass clippings, tend to break down faster. These materials provide the protein that microorganisms need to grow and reproduce.

  • In contrast, brown materials, rich in carbon such as dry leaves, straw, and paper, decompose slower. They serve as an energy source for the decomposers. The size of the materials also plays a part; smaller items have a larger surface area exposed to microbes, leading to quicker decomposition.

  • For an effective composting process, a balanced mix of greens and browns is crucial. An excess of greens can lead to a slimy, smelly mess, while an overload of browns can slow down the decomposition process. It's worth noting that certain items like bones, dairy, and meat should be avoided as they can attract pests and don't break down easily.

2. Bin Conditions:

  • A compost bin’s conditions play a pivotal role in how quickly materials break down. Oxygen is vital for aerobic bacteria (the good guys) to function effectively. These bacteria break down organic matter without creating foul odors. Without sufficient oxygen, anaerobic bacteria dominate, leading to a slower decomposition process and producing a foul smell.

  • Moisture is another key factor. Microorganisms in your compost need water to survive. The ideal compost pile should feel like a wrung-out sponge, moist but not dripping. An overly wet pile can become compacted, reducing airflow and leading to anaerobic conditions.

  • Finally, the size and volume of your pile or bin matter. A larger pile retains heat better, aiding in faster decomposition. However, if the pile is too large, it might restrict oxygen flow to the center. Thus, a medium-sized pile, regularly turned, tends to be the most effective.

3. Climate:

  • Composting is a biological process, and like all such processes, it's influenced by temperature. Warm temperatures accelerate microbial activity, while cold slows it down. In colder regions, composting might come to a near halt during winter, only to restart in spring.

  • Precipitation too plays a role. While moisture is essential for compost, excessive rain can waterlog your pile, driving out oxygen and turning it anaerobic. On the other hand, in arid regions, the compost may dry out and need regular watering.

  • Seasonal changes, therefore, require adjustments. For instance, during rainy seasons, you might need to cover your pile or introduce more brown materials to soak up excess moisture. In contrast, during dry spells, regular watering becomes crucial.

Risks of Over-Extended Composting

1. Oversaturation:

  • Leaving compost in a bin for an extended period can lead to water accumulation, especially if it's exposed to regular rainfall and lacks proper drainage. A saturated compost pile can become anaerobic, causing beneficial bacteria to be replaced by less efficient, odor-producing ones.

  • This oversaturation is not only a setback for decomposition but also a potential health hazard. Anaerobic conditions can foster the growth of harmful pathogens. Plus, a waterlogged compost pile becomes heavy and harder to turn, making aeration even more challenging.

  • To avoid these complications, it’s imperative to ensure your compost bin has adequate drainage. Regular turning can also help in dispersing excess moisture and introducing air back into the pile.

2. Loss of Nutrients:

  • Over time, as materials break down in your compost, nutrients can leach out, especially if the pile remains unchecked for long durations. Rain can wash away valuable nutrients, reducing the quality of your finished compost.

  • Nutrient loss can also occur due to over-decomposition. When compost sits for too long, even after it's mature, microbes continue consuming organic matter, leading to a depletion of certain nutrients.

  • To prevent this, it’s essential to monitor your compost regularly. Once mature, it should be used or stored in a dry place, away from direct rainfall, ensuring its nutrient-rich quality remains intact for your garden.

3. Unwanted Pests:

  • A compost pile that’s left unattended can become a haven for pests. Rats, raccoons, and other critters might find a neglected compost bin an ideal spot for nesting or foraging.

  • A compost pile that remains damp and uneaten by beneficial microbes can attract flies and other unwanted insects. These pests can become a nuisance and can also introduce diseases into your garden ecosystem.

  • Regular maintenance, turning, and ensuring a balanced green-to-brown ratio can deter most pests. Additionally, using a bin with a secure lid and placing the pile away from thickets or woods can reduce the risk of larger animals making your compost their home.

Recognizing Ready-to-Use Compost:


  • Mature compost undergoes a significant transformation from its original state. Raw materials break down into a homogenous, fine mixture. When you examine mature compost, it appears dark, resembling rich garden soil.

  • This dark color indicates the presence of humus, a stable organic compound that's crucial for soil health. Humus improves soil structure, making it easier for plants to root and access nutrients.

  • If you spot large chunks or materials that haven't decomposed, it might indicate that the composting process isn't complete. It’s advisable to sieve these larger pieces out before using the compost or to return them to the bin for further decomposition.


  • A mature compost emits a pleasant, earthy aroma. This scent is reminiscent of a forest floor after rain. If your compost smells sour, rotten, or like ammonia, it's a sign that the decomposition process has gone awry.

  • An unpleasant smell can indicate a variety of issues, from over-saturation to an imbalance in the green-to-brown ratio. Addressing these issues and giving the compost more time can often correct the problem.

  • Always trust your nose. Good compost should never smell putrid. A foul odor is a clear sign that something is off, and using such compost can harm plants or introduce pathogens to the soil.


  • To assess the moisture content and texture of your compost, it's essential to feel it. Mature compost has a soft, crumbly texture, similar to cake crumbs. It should hold together when squeezed but crumble easily when you release the pressure.

  • In terms of moisture, mature compost is damp but not soggy. When squeezed, it shouldn’t release water. If it does, it indicates oversaturation, which can be remedied by adding more brown materials or exposing the compost to the sun.

  • A mature compost also feels cool to the touch. If it's still warm, it means microbial activity is ongoing, and the composting process hasn't reached its end.

Tips to Speed Up the Composting Process:

1. Regular Turning:

  • One of the most effective ways to hasten the composting process is to turn the pile regularly. Turning introduces oxygen, facilitating aerobic bacteria to thrive. These bacteria are the powerhouses of decomposition, breaking down organic matter efficiently.

  • Regular turning also helps distribute moisture evenly throughout the pile, preventing pockets of oversaturation or dryness.

  • While the frequency of turning depends on various factors like climate and materials, a general rule of thumb is to turn the compost once a week. Using tools like compost aerators or pitchforks can make this task easier.

2. Maintain Moisture:

  • As discussed, moisture is vital for microbial life. Keeping the compost pile at the right moisture level can significantly speed up decomposition. Think of it as maintaining the consistency of a wrung-out sponge.

  • In arid regions or during dry spells, you might need to water your compost pile. Conversely, in rainy conditions, covering the compost or adding brown materials can help prevent oversaturation.

  • Using a spray hose to add moisture or a tarp to shield the pile from excessive rain can be beneficial in maintaining the desired moisture balance.

3. Chop Materials:

  • The size of the materials you add to your compost plays a pivotal role in how quickly they decompose. Smaller pieces offer more surface area for microbes to work on, accelerating the decomposition process.

  • Before adding garden waste, kitchen scraps, or other materials to your compost, consider chopping, shredding, or breaking them down into smaller bits.

  • Tools like garden shredders, pruners, or even kitchen blenders can be employed to reduce the size of materials. This little extra effort can shave weeks or even months off the composting timeline.

When to Empty and Start Fresh

Seasonal Considerations:

  • The seasons play an influential role in the composting process. Decomposition is faster in warmer temperatures, which is why many gardeners find summer to be the peak composting season.

  • Emptying your compost bin in early spring provides you with nutrient-rich material to enrich your soil just in time for planting season. This compost can help seeds and young plants get a robust start, aiding in strong root development and overall growth.

  • Conversely, emptying in the fall provides a protective layer for garden beds, replenishing the soil's nutrients in preparation for the next growing season. It also makes room in your compost bin for fall garden cleanup debris and leaves.


  • Your compost bin's volume can be a practical indicator of when to empty it. As decomposition progresses, you'll notice the pile shrinking. Once the bin is full and the bottom layers appear mature, it's time to harvest.

  • Keep in mind that if the top layers haven't fully decomposed when the bottom has, you can sift through the compost. Use the matured compost for your plants and return the unfinished material back to the bin.

  • Remember, composting is a continuous cycle. As you remove mature compost from the bottom, continue adding fresh materials to the top to keep the process ongoing.

Starting Over:

  • Sometimes, despite our best efforts, a compost pile can go astray. Maybe it's become oversaturated, too dry, or perhaps an imbalance in materials has slowed down the decomposition process.

  • In such cases, it might be beneficial to start afresh. Empty the bin, set aside any mature compost, and reevaluate your composting ingredients and methods.

  • If you're starting over, consider layering green and brown materials in a balanced manner, ensuring adequate moisture, and committing to regular turning. With these revamped practices, your new compost pile will be off to a promising start.


Composting, in essence, is a balance of science and patience. Recognizing when compost is ready, understanding the factors influencing its maturity, and knowing how to expedite the process can immensely benefit gardeners of all levels. While the timeline can vary, with observation and understanding, you can ensure your compost remains a rich, nutritious supplement for your garden.

Your journey to sustainable gardening doesn't end here. Every batch of compost you produce contributes to a healthier planet, one pile at a time. Happy composting!


bottom of page